Shop the Best Formal Jewelry Under $500 That Looks Over $500

Oct 17, 2023

Us Weekly has affiliate partnerships so we may receive compensation for some links to products and services. Updated on April 26, 2023.

To quote How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days, "Ladies, frost yourselves." They say that diamonds are a girl's best friend, but our budgets prefers imitation diamonds instead. The truth is, most people can't even spot the difference between the two!

With wedding season in full swing and fancy fall events on the horizon, bills are starting to pile up — gifts and gowns galore! Don't feel like you have to add to the expenses by buying formal jewelry. You can still shine with budget-friendly baubles that won't break the bank. We went on a mission to find the best necklaces, earrings and bracelets under $50 that look like they’re over $500. Unlike with J.Lo, people will be fooled by the rocks that you got!

This Silver Necklace and Earrings Jewelry Set

Silver lining! This set of silver and cubic zirconia jewelry looks like it's from designer David Yurman. The pendant necklace and matching stud earrings are simple yet stunning! One reviewer reported, "Not only have they held up, but they look great and I get compliments on the set at work and with my family. 10/10 would buy for anyone."

Get the Amazon Collection Sterling Silver Cubic Zirconia Halo Pendant Necklace and Stud Earrings Jewelry Set for just $33 at Amazon! Please note, prices are accurate at the date of publication, July 29, 2022, but are subject to change.

These Crystal Fringe Earrings

Don't go chasing waterfalls, unless they’re these waterfall earrings! Add some sparkle and shine to any special occasion with these crystal fringe earrings. Plated with 18-karat gold, these lightweight jewels will dress you up without weighing you down. One shopper declared, "These crystal drop earrings are a MUST! Perfect for holidays or any time you want to give off major GLAM 🙂 The perfect size, not too large or too small. Love the statement they make!"

Get the Ettika Crystal Fringe Drop Earrings for just $39 (originally $55) at Nordstrom!

These Pearl Stud Earrings

Girl with the pearl earring! These earrings from Anthropologie are simple yet stunning! Every gal needs a pair of pearl studs in her jewelry box. As one shopper said, "Perfect staple for everyone's closet." Classic and chic!

Get the Tai Pearl Studs for just $38 at Anthropologie!

This Silver Rhinestone Drop Necklace

Dazzle with this dainty silver rhinestone drop necklace! One customer gushed, "This is so pretty and delicate. I am wearing it on my wedding day and it compliments my dress perfectly. I also love that I can wear it more than once with how simple it is. LOVE IT!"

Get the Love of the Light Sterling Silver Rhinestone Drop Necklace for just $26 at Lulus!

This Rose Gold Tennis Bracelet

All that glitters is (rose) gold! For a subtle pop of pink, try this gorgeous tennis bracelet made with cubic zirconia crystals on a gold-plated frame. According to one review, "This one is a real beauty — looks like a million bucks. Very happy with it — dainty on my wrist and just a beautiful style."

Get the SWEETV Women's Wedding Bridal Bracelet for just $19 (originally $22) at Amazon! Please note, prices are accurate at the date of publication, July 29, 2022, but are subject to change.

This Gold-Plated Necklace and Earrings Set

Sparkle and shine in this exquisite gold-plated necklace and earrings set! This review captured our thoughts perfectly: "We literally gasped when we opened the box! Looks very high quality and the way it shines you would think it's real diamonds."

Get the Weiman Jewelry White Gold/Gold Plated Women Cubic Zirconia CZ Marquise Teardrop Bridal Tennis Necklace and Drop Earring Set for just $36 at Amazon! Please note, prices are accurate at the date of publication, July 29, 2022, but are subject to change.

Looking for additional ways to elevate your jewelry collection? Check out more picks below:

This post is brought to you by Us Weekly's Shop With Us team. The Shop With Us team aims to highlight products and services our readers might find interesting and useful, such as wedding-guest outfits, purses, plus-size swimsuits, women's sneakers, bridal shapewear, and perfect gift ideas for everyone in your life. Product and service selection, however, is in no way intended to constitute an endorsement by either Us Weekly or of any celebrity mentioned in the post.

The Shop With Us team may receive products free of charge from manufacturers to test. In addition, Us Weekly receives compensation from the manufacturer of the products we write about when you click on a link and then purchase the product featured in an article. This does not drive our decision as to whether or not a product or service is featured or recommended. Shop With Us operates independently from the advertising sales team. We welcome your feedback at [email protected]. Happy shopping!